My Top 5 QB's of all-time

[3Peatkb24]

1. Joe Montana
2. John Unitas
3. Tom Brady
4. John Elway
5. Peyton Manning (OMAHA)
-Based on ability, being able to carry a team, Titles won, Games won, MVP's, Clutchness!
I cant wait for Denver/New England, OMAHA.

[lakerevolution]

It's probably high-time to drop Johnny U from the list and go post-merger, considering how much the game and the position has evolved. Would Unitas have been able to handle a Lawrence Taylor, Michael Strahan, Jared Allen, Ndamukong Suh, Deion Sanders, Champ Bailey, Darrelle Revis or Richard Sherman? Of course you could say that if he had the pass protectors and receivers of today he'd still shine, but who knows.

[3Peatkb24]

since the merger
1. Joe
2. Tommy
3. Elway
4. Peyton
5. Marino - I know, no rings but we know. Sorry but he is better than Bradshaw or Aikman, JMO

[3Peatkb24]

Peyton smoked Rodgers, Omaha, I mean 29-10. Come on man? Tom is getting ready to get his too and when he loses in Milehigh he wont Repeat, than he will start fading next season.

[lakerevolution]

The Broncos opened up a fresh can on Green Bay early last night and just never let them become a factor. Denver's defense is impressive and is doing what it's supposed to do: Get the ball back in Peyton's hands. Aaron Rogers must feel like he got double-triple checked.

[KobeMVP888]

I'm a huge Montana fan, but Tom Brady is hands down the greatest QB of all-time.

[3Peatkb24]

My teams are struggling this year, Colts/Lakers/Cubs and Mets both lost but there is always 1 guy I can count on 95% of the time and it's Peyton. I won a huge bet betting on Denver last night and I even gave up 7 points in doing so. It wasn't money involved but my bet was with my sister, she quit smoking if Denver wins and I would have to help buy her new car if GB wins. If I catch her smoking now

[3Peatkb24]

I'm a huge Montana fan, but Tom Brady is hands down the greatest QB of all-time.

No he isn't, he lost to Eli twice in the SB so that alone clobbers his legacy plus he is a cheater. Peyton is 2-1 against him in Title games too. Take Belichick out of the equation and who knows what Tom would've been? I still have him in my Top 5 and it's because of his resume mainly. In all honesty Tom isn't near the passer that Dan Marino was.

[lakerevolution]

Tom is most comparable to Joe Montana. But would Joe have been Joe without HOF coaches and players to work with? Virtually every HOF QB has benefitted from a HOF coach.

[3Peatkb24]

Tom is most comparable to Joe Montana. But would Joe have been Joe without HOF coaches and players to work with? Virtually every HOF QB has benefitted from a HOF coach.

Joe was 4-0 SB's and took 2 different teams to the Conference Championship. He took the Chiefs to a Final4 and the Chiefs haven't won a Playoff game since then. Joe has 0 INT's in the big game, had Tom went 19-0 and beat Eli then I would have him #1 as well. You cant be the best ever when your team is 18-0 and favored by 14 points in the SB and lose to a Wildcard team led by Eli Manning who isn't even in the Top 30 all-time. Not only that Tom's team lost to Eli again in 2011 and he played like garbage. I respect Ken's opinion though but I would take Joe over him anyday. Passing Wise Peyton and Marino both are better too but they just don't have the Championships to back up any debate I can come with.

[3Peatkb24]

Bradshaw has his share of SB wins and SB MVPs. Can't discount that.

On another note, Luck looks like shit. Cam ate him for lunch,

Andrew hasn't looked right all season but he is playing with broken ribs. Actually He and Cam played evenly and the Colts had the game won if the Defense could get one stop. In the 4th Qtr, Andrew looked great. Cam does look pretty good this season though. Colts just fired their OC - Pep. Having said that I don't see the Colts beating Denver this week either. They are in trouble.

[Lakers4Life]

Dan Marino
Joe Montana
Warren Moon
Jim Plunkett
Bret Favre
John Elway
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady